Top 10 Picks: Our 2012 Halloween Favorites October 30, 2012 by The Gifting Experts 1. Deviled Egg Eyeballs, 2. 3-D Pumpkin Cookies, 3. Pumpkin Teeth, 4. Worm Ice, 5. Glow Stick Costume, 6. Severed Finger Invitation, 7. Halloween Fruit, 8. Witch Crash, 9. Vampire Fang Napkin Rings, 10. Screaming Red Punch with a Hand